Do they belong to you? Claim these comments.
Nicole
Is this you? Claim Profile »
1 year ago
in Battlestar Galactica: Revelations on Webomatica
I do not agree with this analysis for one simple reason. We are forgetting the prophesy that says a dying leader will lead the people to earth, but die before she sees it through. If this is earth, than the prophesy was wrong. I do not believe this is earth, I believe this was the cylon homeworld that was destroyed which explains why the cylons are so keen on finding earth, because they themselves need a new home world.
show all 3 replies
3 replies
webomatica
actually that is a possibility that I didn't think of. there is no indication in this Revelations episodes that this in fact, our earth, only Gaeta's mention of the constellations lining up. I wonder if Starbuck led them on the wrong path and to their doom as that hybrid mentioned. What would be really insanely cool is if it turns out this is all some huge Cylon trap to lead them off track and then attack them?
boxlight
> We are forgetting the prophesy that says a dying leader will lead the people to earth, but die before she sees it through.
We're not forgetting it, but the writers are. The writers have been making this show up on a week-to-week basis since the "two years later" jump on New Caprica. The show has not had coherency or meaningful direction for a long, long time.
"And they have a plan." They most certainly do not.
We're not forgetting it, but the writers are. The writers have been making this show up on a week-to-week basis since the "two years later" jump on New Caprica. The show has not had coherency or meaningful direction for a long, long time.
"And they have a plan." They most certainly do not.
JKP
Unlikely. This was Earth. The city had all the appearances of New York City, no less. The plot twist you suggest is the sort of hack writing that so far, we have not seen from RDM.