DISQUS

DISQUS Hello!  The comments on this profile are unclaimed and thus are unverified.

Do they belong to you? Claim these comments.

kirk hodgman's picture

Unregistered

Feeds

aliases

  • kirk hodgman
  • some guy

kirk hodgman

1 year ago

in The Atheist’s Dilemma: Logical Conclusions to the Lack of Free Will on dmiessler.com | grep understanding
Excellent post, his argument may have some validity, but his argument is ultimately flawed. Your original point was, IF christianity was right, then we essentially have no free will. Your argument applied to how christian-free-will is a logical fallacy. I personally believe in free will and that people are responisble for their actions, and because I don't believe in a god, i believe free will can exist with no logical contradictions. Your argument was perfectly right, and his point about the consiquences of not believing in free will is also right, but aren't necessarily connected. I'm not sure if you realized it so i thought i would point that out. Your post seemed like you were admitting you were wrong... Just trying to help.

1 year ago

in The Atheist’s Dilemma: Logical Conclusions to the Lack of Free Will on danielmiessler.com | grep understanding
Excellent post, his argument may have some validity, but his argument is ultimately flawed. Your original point was, IF christianity was right, then we essentially have no free will. Your argument applied to how christian-free-will is a logical fallacy. I personally believe in free will and that people are responisble for their actions, and because I don't believe in a god, i believe free will can exist with no logical contradictions. Your argument was perfectly right, and his point about the consiquences of not believing in free will is also right, but aren't necessarily connected. I'm not sure if you realized it so i thought i would point that out. Your post seemed like you were admitting you were wrong... Just trying to help.
Returning? Login