DISQUS

DISQUS Hello!  The comments on this profile are unclaimed and thus are unverified.

Do they belong to you? Claim these comments.

Tom W.'s picture

Unregistered

Feeds

aliases

  • Tom W.
  • Tom W.
  • Tom W.
  • Tom Watson

Tom W.

1 year ago

in “They become their parents.” on newcritics
Hey, I thought this was an excellent debut - I came in with less than a abundant appreciation of The Graduate, and now I want to watch it in full again to see how everyone's insight stacks up.

And I can't wait till next - that's a movie I love: In the Heat of the Night.

1 year ago

in Edwards to Endorse Obama Tonight on Shakesville
Wait, did Obama call Edwards "sweetie?"

1 year ago

in Why I Post About Politics On This Blog on A VC
Thanks Fred - I'm more of a junkie that you are, and heavily invested in the race. Actually, your readers have wider perspectives on politics than I normally find out there. Mo - I'm with you on seasoning, very much so.

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Wow, I feel just the opposite - to me, "chosen one" is much scarier.
1 reply
Greg Cannon I guess the difference is that the "chosen one" schtick is Obama getting caught up in the moment. I don't think the guy has a messianic character. If I did, I'd steer clear of him. And I guess I think that, in the end, the reality of the Oval Office will knock him back to reality whereas I don't think that will be enough to cure Hillary of what I think ails her. In fact, I think it will only make things worse.

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Michael, no one said you're a misogynist - I respect your choice (though it seems you don't respect mine - the anti-Clinton stuff just came tumbling out there). I do believe that Senator Obama would be better served by not remaining silent on the bitter sexist attacks on his opponent - someone, by the way, who shares virtually all of his policy views when compared to the GOP, and someone whose constituency he'd need quite desperately in the fall.

No one said you're cultish either. That doesn't mean the cult ain't out there, because it is. And I don't get a "sense of country" from the Obama movement. I get a sense of savior - and I naturally recoil. Can't help it. Just me, but many others feel the same way.

And yeah, I'm a cynic - I don't believe in the audacity of hope. I think it's crap (indeed, not even a decent metaphor English - hope isn't audacious, it's more of a common denominator). A pop slogan. Give me universal health care in the richest nation on the planet instead.
1 reply
Michael Tom, please allow me to put this plainly: You wrote a post levying certain assertions, and I challenged them. It's fair and fine if we disagree, but backpedaling on those assertions (and their effect) after the fact is ... well, you're better than that. (And for the ur-literal: no, you did not categorically state I am a misogynist; I followed your line of "sexist" / "feminist" accusations to their logical conclusion in a manner actually less-frothing as the way in which you issued them.)

But perhaps you were indeed too cynical -- 'The Audacity of Hope' was meant as mini-teleology, an ironic twist on what Jed Purdy might otherwise have entitled 'For Common Things', the finality or end-run of cynicism. It's no wonder that eluded you! ; )

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Greg - I actually went the other way on "not screwing up" part. The whole movement feel on Obama's side is so troubling. Part of him seems to be a regular progressive Democrat, and another part seems to accept "The One" status - which could get us into tons of trouble on every front. With Hillary, I know exactly what I'm getting. And I respect her.
1 reply
Greg Cannon In the end, I will of course support her if she's the nominee. My two biggest problems with her: Iraq and the sense that she's entitled to the nomination. For me, the latter is worse than Obama's willingness to accept the "chosen one" mantle.

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Where? Link? (He certainly did it very quietly if what you're saying is true)

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Well, that two families stuff is just there to disqualify the "wife of..." even though she's more qualified. I don't like that argument very much. It's not her fault George Bush is president. And yeah, the cynicism is baked in - when this cult crashes (because the expectations are now out there for some vast religious awakening that won't happen) it will be very, very ugly indeed.
2 replies
charlie crystle Obama spoke out about the pimping statement. pay attention.
Greg Cannon I'm supporting Obama, but actually expecting little from him beyond the basics of not actively screwing things up a la Bush. And while it's not Hillary's "fault" that Bill got to the White House first, she can't very well claim those two terms on her resume and then blame me and many like me for having Clinton fatigue. It's not her "fault" she's married to Bill, but it's not mine either.

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Three aspects to the sexism thing, all troubling:

- Obama's supporters everywhere on the mainstream Democratic sites, blogs, boards. Tons of nasty "little old lady" comments, referencing right-wing talking points, and general shouting down of pro-Hillary feminist viewpoints. (BTW, this has also happened at some caucus sites). The campaign is silent.

- The anti-Clinton media machine, with its virulently anti-woman tone, the most recent example being Matthews and Shuster on MSNBC (apologies, suspension) but also Maureen Dowd, Andrew Sullivan, myriad others. Obama's silence, particularly on the Shuster "pimping" comment, was telling to me. How easily he could have gained points with feminists!

- Finally, the attitude of the candidate himself - "likeable enough," "tea parties," "the claws come out," the snub. All very telling, and kind of ugly.

The cult does exist, and its religious is there, from Oprah on down - the idea of "The One." Very ant-American to me. And yes, I'm cynical - I cop to that. I used to cover politics in the Bronx way back in the day, so it's scrubbed in.
3 replies
Greg Cannon Tom, I'm a former reporter myself so I know of what you speak. I'm making a conscious effort to be less cynical (quitting the newspaper business certainly helped ;-) You raise some valid points, but I don't think Obama should have to apologize for for some ninny on cable said or even make a point to denounce it. And while he's certainly milking the "cult" thing, you can't blame him for attracting that kind of following in the first place. What I see as unAmerican is the prospect of entering a third decade under the leadership of one of the same two families. Enough.
Ethan Bauley's picture
Ethan Bauley Tom's criticisms are somewhat legitimate but they are pretty pale compared to Larry Lessig's withering critique of Clinton's mischaracterizations and knowingly false statements about Obama's record.

Larry Lessig on Obama v. Clinton

Lessig was right when he termed these tactics "Rovean", as in Karl Rove. I love both Clintons' policies but they are completely committed to working within an unsustainable system.

Clinton thinks "change" means "no more Bush"; it really means shifting the culture of Washington, which starts with where the money comes from. And Obama is leading the way there (among other important places he is innovating).
show all 3 replies

1 year ago

in The Google President on A VC
Fred, you may be right but I hope you're wrong. Even more so tan the Google comparison, Obama has to tamp down concerns over the cultish/religious aspect of his campaig, and some of the outright sexism of some of his supporters and fans in the media.

"Only one Google" - the arrogance!
1 reply
Greg Cannon Sincere question: What examples of sexism from the Obama camp? Not saying there haven't been any, just not aware of them. I am aware, however, of the race politics being played by the Clintons. As for the "cultish" aspects of the campaign, frankly that just strikes me as cynicism on the part of people who are so past believing that a politician could possible inspire hope in people. If that's true than we really are done for and there's no sense paying attention to this whole thing in the first place.

1 year ago

in The New Outside.in on A VC
outside.in should have a charity/causes/events/volunteers aspect to it - now that would get viral

1 year ago

in Ganging Up On The Leader on A VC
"The thing that always happens in Risk is everyone starts ganging up on the leader. It's the only way to stop someone who has control of large continents with lots of armies."

Ha - that could be describing the presidential race, Fred.

1 year ago

in Closing Out Comments On Older Posts? on A VC
Fred, I'd personally never close out comments on the old posts - I have several years-old threads that I love. Bet you have a few - I'd urge you not to close the old threads.

2 years ago

in Confession of a Schizophrenic Movie Fan on newcritics
Siren said that these flicks "appeals to the still very male critical establishment, and therefore gets more respect."

Bingo. Looking for art.
Returning? Login