DISQUS

DISQUS Hello!  The comments on this profile are unclaimed and thus are unverified.

Do they belong to you? Claim these comments.

dlw's picture

Unregistered

Feeds

aliases

  • dlw
  • dlw
  • ANKoTP

dlw

5 months ago

in My Story on Common Sense Atheism
I believe the distinctives of Christianity, as described by Paul in Athens as recorded in the book of Acts, are well characterized as hypotheses that cannot be verified in their truth value in this life-time.

I don't believe there would be any cause to remember them if Jesus had not died and rose again and that the concrete referents of this stem from the witness of followers of Christ. I believe once we control for the impact of the Constantinization of Christianity that the effects are pretty impressive. It is mainly when monotheism is coupled with imperialism that tragedy strikes, this has been exacerbated by virtue of how our progress in understanding of the physical world has not been matched by progress in loving our neighbors. I also think the Bible's aesthetics are absolutely wonderful and under gird much that is good in our world. I love how it is the only religious book that requires people to understand the geography of a place. I think it contains the roots of our understanding of History and much else...

Here's where I describe my views at Recovering Evangelical.
http://www.recoveringevangelical.com/profile/dlw

peace out.

5 months ago

in The Taming of God (Obama’s Religion, pt 2) on the Jesus Manifesto
I guess I'm defending civil religion as better than state-churchyness and glossing over the inconsistency Obama has in putting forth his faith very much in terms consistent with the sort of civil religion that used to prevail in the US(before we became increasingly hyper-individualistic or "free to choose").

I think one could also see God's test of Abraham as having a secondary purpose of revealing God's displeasure with human sacrifice or treating humans as objects.

This sure as gehenna ain't a universal value, but it ought to be and so I think your point is valid in terms of how we ought to react to his language and yet I think we can also cut Obama some slack. All theology is contextual and we all do theology, regardless of whether we've been syndicated professionally or not, and Obama's context for the theology above is working within the US gov't.

dlw

5 months ago

in Wednesday Ballot on the Jesus Manifesto
"real progress" happens because of acts of self-sacrificial love w.o. hypocripsy, but that doesn't mean that voting doesn't matter. One doesn't have to buy into the idealizations of gov't to believe that. Gov't isn't an autonomous entity, it is an object of capture by a variety of groups or interests to use its monopoly on the use of legit violence towards their own ends.

So it matters that people discipline themselves to take their duty of citizenship seriously so as to check the abuse of political power and, as I believe, it is possible to do this w.o. detracting significantly from a much stronger commitment to our neighborhoods and communities.

dlw

6 months ago

in The Cross as…Political Jujitsu on the Jesus Manifesto
Dude, did you borrow the phrase "political jujitsu" from me?

dlw

6 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
Dude, did you borrow the phrase "political jujitsu" from me?


dlw

6 months ago

in Wednesday Ballot on the Jesus Manifesto
people died so that AAmericans could vote. Now, you're saying you don't think that voting matters.

If you think both main alternatives are equally bad, the logical thing is to flip a coin and hope that others who feel the same also flip a coin. This will make the election closer and add a degree of randomness to the final outcome that will force intere$t group$ to hedge their bets.

dlw
1 reply
Dave C And again I say, real change happens in your neighborhood and community. Soldiers died to perpetuate the myth of a caring, democratic government that has the has the best interest of the people at heart. Government exists only to further itself, to gather power and resources. People are only a resource. Once the government figures out how to get along with out people, voting rights will be gone. It's already happening: When was the last time the people actually had a choice in who the voted for? The haven't for decades. They are given a choice of candidates that has been chosen for them by insiders.

6 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
people died so that AAmericans could vote. Now, you're saying you don't think that voting matters.


If you think both main alternatives are equally bad, the logical thing is to flip a coin and hope that others who feel the same also flip a coin. This will make the election closer and add a degree of randomness to the final outcome that will force intere$t group$ to hedge their bets.



dlw

6 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
We are accountable to make all of our lives a witness to Christ.


Your post illustrates though that the biblical definition of the poor is different than the modernist definition of the poor, which, though purporting to be scientific, is full of conceptual difficulties, except per se when it comes to matters of extreme poverty.



So I guess I'd simply say the slogan "preferential option for the poor" sounds nice, but I think its unproductive to put any slogan as central to our calling to communicate the identity and significance of Christ in our contexts. If we, as communities of Christ-followers, take seriously the need to reform our received institutions to abridge our most certainly bounded altruisms then that will bless all sorts of people who arguably fit the biblical notion of "the poor" for a variety of reasons.



dlw

7 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
It seems that this brings up the issue of the role of the intellectual within the church and how we should relate to the vestiges of Constantinized Christianity we are a part of or have been influenced by and are often committed to.


I am post-creedal, so I don't believe a shared confession/rule of faith is what shd unite us. It seems a good deal of scholarship is about denominational business/politics and thereby seperated by some degrees from helping "the poor" or the masses of individuals afloat without a firm foundation.



I guess I'd like to see the gift of discernment among followers of Christ used in the way we steward our received institutions and consider the many possible ways we can manifest Christ in our contexts.



Here are some things I've written that make the generalities above a little more clear...

here's the link to mes pensees neo-huguenot.

http://www.theooze.com/forums/discussions.cfm?f...



Here's also the last post I made on my house church model for political activism.

http://sodsbrood.com/antimani/2007/02/08/1021/

dlw

7 months ago

in The Taming of God (Obama’s Religion, pt 2) on the Jesus Manifesto
I'm a believer that as Christians we can express our beliefs differently publicly and privately (among other committed believers). Obama typifies a good example of how we can stand by our faith without (mis)aligning it with what is universal or what we are objectively justified in bringing down to bear on all others. In my mind, this uses State-Churchy speak to subvert State-Churchiness.

dlw
1 reply
bren0110 well I certainly didn't mean to exposit Obama's speech to show that it is subversive. On the contrary, I was trying to show that it is a perfect example of civil religion. I would say that we should express our beliefs with different purposes and with a different tenor in public, but I think the essential content of our beliefs should not change when expressed in public. But it is the impulse to have a public voice in full that has led us to bend our faith to fit the rules of public discourse in this country. That was my point.

7 months ago

in The Taming of God (Obama’s Religion, pt 2) on the Jesus Manifesto
good thoughts.

I think of Paul's dream that made him go to Macedonia instead of East. If he had not had that dream, the initial center for the development of followers of Christ would have been quite different. I also think of the time in Babylonian captivity and how other people groups were similarly moved to Babylon and then allowed to return home after the Persians defeated the Babylonians without extensive blood-shed. If this truly was the time of Daniel/Deutero-Isaiah and the time of spiritual renewal for the Jews(when most of the OT was edited/compiled) then it stands to reason that seeds/(points of contact) were planted and scattered among the Greeks and other nations. Not the whole, but important parts, w. different parts scattered in different areas, thus creating quite different tasks for followers of Christ in communicating the identity and significance of Christ using the native tongues.

dlw

7 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
I'm a believer that as Christians we can express our beliefs differently publicly and privately (among other committed believers). Obama typifies a good example of how we can stand by our faith without (mis)aligning it with what is universal or what we are objectively justified in bringing down to bear on all others. In my mind, this uses State-Churchy speak to subvert State-Churchiness.


dlw

7 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
good thoughts.


I think of Paul's dream that made him go to Macedonia instead of East. If he had not had that dream, the initial center for the development of followers of Christ would have been quite different. I also think of the time in Babylonian captivity and how other people groups were similarly moved to Babylon and then allowed to return home after the Persians defeated the Babylonians without extensive blood-shed. If this truly was the time of Daniel/Deutero-Isaiah and the time of spiritual renewal for the Jews(when most of the OT was edited/compiled) then it stands to reason that seeds/(points of contact) were planted and scattered among the Greeks and other nations. Not the whole, but important parts, w. different parts scattered in different areas, thus creating quite different tasks for followers of Christ in communicating the identity and significance of Christ using the native tongues.



dlw

7 months ago

in The Taming of God (Obama’s Religion, pt 2) on the Jesus Manifesto
not sure human sacrifice would have been considered universal in Abraham's day....

A lot of things we take for granted are due to the extent that the kingship of God has been advancing, often in ways we aren't so aware of.
dlw

7 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
not sure human sacrifice would have been considered universal in Abraham's day....


A lot of things we take for granted are due to the extent that the kingship of God has been advancing, often in ways we aren't so aware of.

dlw

8 months ago

in Electing for Change on the Jesus Manifesto
Unless, you think you have a good reason not to vote, in which case there still is an incentive for parties to become more relevant for more people, tho our winner-takes-all political elections do not encourage the main parties to court non-voters much.
dlw

8 months ago

in Electing for Change on the Jesus Manifesto
please check out my idea at "A New Kind of Third Party".

I'd encourage you to get your local third parties behind state-level election reform 100% and then focus on those elections where they may win and vote quasi-strategically in all other elections.

The goal is to maximize the influence of us outsiders subject to the constraint of the continuation of a two-party dominated system.

dlw

8 months ago

in Electing for Change on the Jesus Manifesto
I operate with a post-babylonian captivity and post-resurrection Xtn world-view that accepts that the powers-that-be will worship "idols" and yet that they also serve a purpose in the advancement of the kingship of God. I need not destroy them, I merely ought to point to Jesus, in all aspects of my life, as the true hope for our future.

dlw

8 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
Unless, you think you have a good reason not to vote, in which case there still is an incentive for parties to become more relevant for more people, tho our winner-takes-all political elections do not encourage the main parties to court non-voters much.
dlw

8 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
please check out my idea at "A New Kind of Third Party".


I'd encourage you to get your local third parties behind state-level election reform 100% and then focus on those elections where they may win and vote quasi-strategically in all other elections.



The goal is to maximize the influence of us outsiders subject to the constraint of the continuation of a two-party dominated system.



dlw

8 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
I operate with a post-babylonian captivity and post-resurrection Xtn world-view that accepts that the powers-that-be will worship "idols" and yet that they also serve a purpose in the advancement of the kingship of God. I need not destroy them, I merely ought to point to Jesus, in all aspects of my life, as the true hope for our future.


dlw

8 months ago

in Electing for Change on the Jesus Manifesto
I'd also say that it's not simply black and white. We also must choose what habits/rules guide us in our vote. That is just as important as whether we vote for two reasons.
1. Shallow Voters have helped to weaken significantly the checks and balances on our gov't in the past.
2. The system wants us to spend way too much time immersed in the streams of (mis)information, particularly on the candidates in elections where our vote matters the least.

So it goes both ways, I'd say I am committed to a two-party dominated political system that necessarily keeps my "ideal" from gaining power, simply because this ties me to the mast as a political outsider to focus more on the politics of conversion.

dlw
1 reply
Casey You make two very valid points. The Framers understood that our democratic-republic would only work with an educated and informed populace. The mainstream media has become part of the misinformation problem. They define the subject and parameters of public debate. Anything outside of their box is marginalized.

The obscure third party candidates I vote for in national elections have zero impact. My voice does have an impact in my local community, however. Mass transit, green initiatives, road construction, police etc are all local issues which are affected by my vote. Besides, standing in the voter line gives one a chance to meet neighbors.

8 months ago

in Electing for Change on the Jesus Manifesto
I'd say it's engrained in us in the US from early on in our public schools...

I see a commitment to democracy as consistent w. a commitment to try to love one's neighbor as oneself better given the persistent fact that we are all bounded in our altruism for other's whose lives intersect our own.

The real "heresy" is the way democracy is de-institutionalized, drawing attention away from the fact that it is the habits people have in voting(and the rest of life) that are of far greater significance than the specific system used to determine changes in political leadership. This is why we shdn't be pressing for "democracy" in the rest of the world. It really is something that needs to come from the bottom-up rather than the top-down. I sincerely doubt our political system wd have "worked" if it had not been for the Great Awakenings that made it become more dynamic.

dlw

8 months ago

in Electing for Change on the Jesus Manifesto
I wdn't use the word "destroy", tho whenever you change people's habits, things do fall apart.

I've been in Ukraine and follow Ukrainian politics, we almost went down that path and I believe it is important that we be salt and light in making our democracy work better. This is part of our witness to others. We need not obsess about nat'l elections to participate in this matter. A relatively small group that votes apart from its self-interest and the spin of the system can change things and attract attention from those who sadly do get preoccupied w. the capture of the state and then inevitably get burned-out and callous to such matters.

dlw
1 reply
hewhocutsdown's picture
hewhocutsdown Destroy may have been the wrong choice of word, but as I wrote it I was envisioning Gideon (translated, literally, as 'The Destroyer') in Judges 6:

Then Gideon took ten men of his servants, and did as the LORD had said unto him: and so it was, because he feared his father's household, and the men of the city, that he could not do it by day, that he did it by night. And when the men of the city arose early in the morning, behold, the altar of Baal was cast down, and the grove was cut down that was by it, and the second bullock was offered upon the altar that was built. And they said one to another, Who hath done this thing? And when they enquired and asked, they said, Gideon the son of Joash hath done this thing.

Then the men of the city said unto Joash, Bring out thy son, that he may die: because he hath cast down the altar of Baal, and because he hath cut down the grove that was by it. And Joash said unto all that stood against him, Will ye plead for Baal? will ye save him? he that will plead for him, let him be put to death whilst it is yet morning: if he be a god, let him plead for himself, because one hath cast down his altar. Therefore on that day he called him Jerubbaal, saying, Let Baal plead against him, because he hath thrown down his altar.

8 months ago

in the Jesus Manifesto » Maintenance Mode on the Jesus Manifesto
I'd also say that it's not simply black and white. We also must choose what habits/rules guide us in our vote. That is just as important as whether we vote for two reasons.
1. Shallow Voters have helped to weaken significantly the checks and balances on our gov't in the past.

2. The system wants us to spend way too much time immersed in the streams of (mis)information, particularly on the candidates in elections where our vote matters the least.



So it goes both ways, I'd say I am committed to a two-party dominated political system that necessarily keeps my "ideal" from gaining power, simply because this ties me to the mast as a political outsider to focus more on the politics of conversion.



dlw
123...4Next Next
Returning? Login