Do they belong to you? Claim these comments.
Robert S. Porter
Is this you? Claim Profile »
1 year ago
in Positively Heretical? on Will Wilkinson
I've never understood why you and Tyler argue for positive liberty since what you really explain is just the tangible effects of negative liberty. It may be a semantic debate but publically supporting positive liberty just confuses people because it's commonly defined in light of Isiah Berlin.
1 year ago
in The Kost of Kidz on Will Wilkinson
My parents love me and that's all that matters.
I'm going to stay out of the debate because numbers scare me and I think it's much ado about nothing.
That said, my mom insists to this day that she didn't and doesn't like children. She gets much more joy out of being a parent now that my sister and I have grown up.
I'm going to stay out of the debate because numbers scare me and I think it's much ado about nothing.
That said, my mom insists to this day that she didn't and doesn't like children. She gets much more joy out of being a parent now that my sister and I have grown up.
1 year ago
in A Corny Story on Will Wilkinson
My home and current province, Saskatchewan, has always had the proper distinction of being the "breadbasket of the world." I demand an apology! I feel bitter! Where's my gun?
1 year ago
in Tales of the Morally Backward on Will Wilkinson
I'm not debating your point–you're absolutely correct. It is completely and totally morally backwards. I'm not a big fan of central banking but it has absolutely nothing on slavery.
However, your second "1000 words" can be debated. I recently heard a very interesting talk by a historian of the Atlantic World and the slave trade (especially along the Gold Coast), Ty M. Reese, who argued that tight-packing, as the cross section above attempts to show is shrouded in mythology and a product of abolitionist propaganda. This of course is not an attempt to minimize slavery whatsoever. Rather, it is to say that even issues such as this can be mired in errors that undermine ones point.
However, your second "1000 words" can be debated. I recently heard a very interesting talk by a historian of the Atlantic World and the slave trade (especially along the Gold Coast), Ty M. Reese, who argued that tight-packing, as the cross section above attempts to show is shrouded in mythology and a product of abolitionist propaganda. This of course is not an attempt to minimize slavery whatsoever. Rather, it is to say that even issues such as this can be mired in errors that undermine ones point.
1 year ago
in To the Slow and Steady and Smartest Goes the Race on Will Wilkinson
Wow, my major, history, does suprisingly well in these comparisons. But I'll get back to you in a year when I graduate.
1 year ago
in ABJ! on Will Wilkinson
Could you elaborate on how he was a better political theorist? I've found his ideas to be lacking in comparison to Jefferson. Jefferson, for me, was a brilliant theorist who did not practice what he preached and had many inconsistencies. Certainly Jefferson's focus on agriculture and being tied to the land was misguided at best, but I still think his ideas outlined in the Declaration outshine anything Hamilton ever did. Certainly the necessary-and-proper clause is advocating of a Leviathan central government beyond economics, no?
1 year ago
in I Wouldn’t Say Incest Is Best… on Will Wilkinson
Personally I think the government should do genetic testing on everyone then pair people based on these findings.
Seriously, though, that child is going to have an interesting life, but children have certainly been brought up in worse.
Seriously, though, that child is going to have an interesting life, but children have certainly been brought up in worse.
1 year ago
in Wishing Daughters Ill on Will Wilkinson
I don't really think that is a fair reading. He does state "If I had a daughter, I wouldn't want her to get pregnant at 16, for the reasons Will names." I also think it's a bit extreme to conclude that "he’d rather risk the ruin of his daughter’s potential than have her go childless."
In the case that a parent agrees with Caplan's analysis and would prefer an early grandchild above no grandchild, then they would likely have the incentive and desire to help their child to become a success despite poor decision making.
Given that I'm young and childless (and will remains so for the near future as far as I can help it) I'm not convinced that Caplan is wrong. Like Caplan I might prefer an early grandchild to none at all, though certainly not hoping it happened. If you just look at the way some grandmothers react to grandchildren or potential grandchildren I think Bryan might be on to something.
In the case that a parent agrees with Caplan's analysis and would prefer an early grandchild above no grandchild, then they would likely have the incentive and desire to help their child to become a success despite poor decision making.
Given that I'm young and childless (and will remains so for the near future as far as I can help it) I'm not convinced that Caplan is wrong. Like Caplan I might prefer an early grandchild to none at all, though certainly not hoping it happened. If you just look at the way some grandmothers react to grandchildren or potential grandchildren I think Bryan might be on to something.
1 year ago
in How Sex Is Different, Part I on Will Wilkinson
Yes, because Steve Sailer, maestro of foreigners, is a known as someone who gets all the facts right.
1 year ago
in If You Own It, You Can Sell It on Will Wilkinson
I've always looked at it this way. In general, defenders of abortion use the idea of self-ownership, which means that women should be able to choose what they do to their bodies. Yet, when it comes to prostitution (or drugs), these same defenders believe that prostitution is an affront to the choices of women. Leaving aside instances of coercion and abuse, is this not a complete logical disconnect?
I also do not see how one can see a difference between services sexual or otherwise. It must, then, be dependent upon cultural stigmas.
I also do not see how one can see a difference between services sexual or otherwise. It must, then, be dependent upon cultural stigmas.
1 year ago
in Nationalist Moral Chauvinism on Will Wilkinson
I think you just described my extended family.
1 year ago
in The Wave of the Future : Not Not Very Good! on Will Wilkinson
I quite like the Asus. It would never replace my current computer, obviously, but I find it great to take to the university since it is really small. I've always disliked laptops because they are too bulky to carry around but at 7" the Asus is perfect. That said, I'd probably recommend waiting for the second generation.
Probably in the next few years I'll break down and buy an ebook reader since the screens are much better to read from like you say. Also, at 200+ books, I'm probably going to run out of shelf space soon.
Probably in the next few years I'll break down and buy an ebook reader since the screens are much better to read from like you say. Also, at 200+ books, I'm probably going to run out of shelf space soon.
1 year ago
in The Wave of the Future : Not Not Very Good! on Will Wilkinson
You can send me your old books, I'll even pay for shipping.
I was going to buy an ebook reader but I decided to purchase a mini laptop (Asus Eee PC) instead, I just couldn't justify a device soley for book reading purposes, but a fully functioning computer, yes.
I was going to buy an ebook reader but I decided to purchase a mini laptop (Asus Eee PC) instead, I just couldn't justify a device soley for book reading purposes, but a fully functioning computer, yes.