DISQUS

Wes Felter's picture

Unregistered

Feeds

aliases

  • Wes Felter
  • Wes Felter
  • Wes Felter
  • Wes Felter

Wes Felter

3 weeks ago

in Why Libertarians Should Oppose “Shrinkwrap” Contracts on The Technology Liberation Front
So shinkwrap contracts are bad, but clickwrap contracts (virtually the same thing) are good? It's good that commerce is moving online, because then the only way to avoid these one-sided contracts is to not use the Internet?
1 reply
AlexHarris's picture
AlexHarris I would contend that clickwrap contracts are not the same as shrinkwrap contracts. In the shrinkwrap context, I have never actually assented to the terms. I already dickered for the product and received it, but now the seller wants to impose some terms ex post factor. When I buy the new Augustana album on iTunes, however, I agree to Apple's terms before I pay for the files. If I decide that I don't actually want to buy the music, I can simply not form the contract and thereby not bind myself to pay or to Apple's terms (but, of course, I also won't get the product).

The clickwrap case sounds exactly the same to me as a standard form contract. The only difference is that one is online and one is on paper. In either case, my actual agreement to the terms is required - and it is, of course, perfectly within the seller's right to refuse to give me its files or products unless I agree to provisions that it sets forth.

4 weeks ago

in http://www.scripting.com/stories/2008/10/25/windowsOnAmazonDay3.html on Scripting News
4. Instances don't relaunch automatically (I don't understand why), so you're supposed to run two instances and have them check each other.

6. I think there are people who are using EC2 because it's cooler than a VPS, even if it isn't better for their needs.
1 reply
dave's picture
dave Thanks Wes -- that's exactly the kind of advice I need.

That's $93 a month just to run a script that keeps another instance running.

Hmmm.

1 month ago

in Amazon Enhances "The Proto-Cloud" on The Wisdom of Clouds
Of course, competitors can read the complaints in the EC2 forums to help prioritize their development. Or just do a diff between the EC2 feature list and the VI3.5 feature list. :-)

2 months ago

in Let the Cloud Computing OS wars begin! on The Wisdom of Clouds
I am skeptical that VDS will support seamless cross-datacenter migration unless it includes some sort of VPN. (And if it did, customers would probably scream about security. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.) IMO the VPN aspect will be critical for cloudbursting, so we can tell who's serious about it and who's not by this feature.

2 months ago

in Cloud Computing and the Constitution on The Wisdom of Clouds
What about companies incorporated in the USA with facilities elsewhere? (e.g. Rackspace) Is it enough for the data to be physically located outside the US?
1 reply
jamesurquhart Excellent question. I'm just getting to know this issue and the associated laws. I'd welcome comments from anyone with applicable expertise, but I plan on hunting down an answer either way.

2 months ago

in Update: The Cloud Computing Bill of Rights on The Wisdom of Clouds
I don't think encryption can solve the problem. If you want to manipulate data in the cloud, you'd have to decrypt it in the cloud and then you're back to trusting the provider. The window of exposure may be smaller, though.

Also, many SaaS features (especially social ones) are based on the provider indexing and analyzing data, which doesn't work if the data is encrypted.
1 reply
BenjaminEllis I'd second Wes. Encryption helps with confidentiality during transport (and potentially storage), but that doesn't address the privacy issue, since that is more around how data is handled when it is processed. Additionally, encryption adds a very big processing overhead, or a cost overhead if performed in hardware. Privacy is usually solved with policy, ahead of technology.

2 months ago

in Why Every Linux Application Known To Man Will Be SaaS Soon on The Wisdom of Clouds
I agree that $75/month is usually going to be cheaper than hosting it yourself, but it may have a hard time competing with multitenant SaaS that can charge even lower prices. For example, as a customer I might consider Trac-on-EC2 and GitHub to be essentially equivalent, but one starts at $7/month and the other at $75/month.

So you can take any open source app and EC2-ize it, but it 's not a license to print money.

2 months ago

in Why Every Linux Application Known To Man Will Be SaaS Soon on The Wisdom of Clouds
Of course, single-tenant SaaS on EC2 probably has a minimum cost of ~$75/app/customer/month, which limits the addressable market. Although maybe customers would decide to run internal business apps only during business hours if it saves them money.

Food for thought: Is a one cent per hour virtual machine feasible?
1 reply
jamesurquhart Ah, but that $75 includes infrastructure, which would cost for a single tenant app whether directly owned or via hosting providers. When looking at this as a service alone, single tenant may be untenable (without automation to save $$ where possible). However, if comparing to the cost of hosting the same application on the same quality and quantity of resources yourself (or via dedicated hosting), it doesn't look quite so bad.

Good point, though. Most people will quickly look at an app hosted in the cloud as a service, not necessarily an instance of a license.

James

3 months ago

in What Do We Think of “Deep Packet Inspection”? on The Technology Liberation Front
How would I encrypt my traffic to TLF? A VPN service? I don't like the idea of encouraging an arms race where my ISP spends (my) money on DPI and I spend more of my money countering DPI.

Prioritizing VoIP is fine (if it is documented and the customer wants it), but today's DPI boxes are total overkill for that task and I suspect ISPs will always be tempted to use them against their customers' wishes.

3 months ago

in How viral is GPL? (Scripting News) on Scripting News
Maybe plugins for identi.ca/Laconica should be GPLed, but that shouldn't stop anyone from writing a Disqus plugin. GPLed plugins can call whatever APIs they want.

3 months ago

in The Technology Liberation Front » Archive » Regulation begets Regulation on The Technology Liberation Front
I think AACS LA is revoking keys every 90 days (they get cracked much faster than that, but IIRC the contracts don't allow anything more rapid). However, they are only revoking software players and the player vendors just issue updates containing new keys.

http://www.aacsla.com/news/

Even if they decided to revoke standalone players it wouldn't affect non-pirates because each individual player has different keys.

3 months ago

in The Technology Liberation Front » Archive » Cerf on managing networks & the need for industry discussion on The Technology Liberation Front
While filtering outbound spam and bot traffic would undoubtedly benefit the Internet, cutting the customers off might give them more incentive to clean things up. :-)

Botnets also provide a good counter-argument for metered service, since customers will demand refunds for bot traffic, but unless they have detailed traffic accounting (DPI!), ISPs will just have to refund all the overage fees or cancel the customer.

3 months ago

in Twenty Questions for the FCC on Broadband Politics
Hours-long seeding at 128kbps can't cause that much congestion on a 10-20Mbps link, although I guess the transit costs could be substantial: 13GB/day. Hmmmm.

3 months ago

in Twenty Questions for the FCC on Broadband Politics
I wonder if any WISPs have considered something like a 128kbps,10MB token bucket; it's neutral, it should satisfy light users, and it limits hogging.

4 months ago

in My browser needs 16 exabytes on Linux Hater's Blog
Several OSes solved the library problem by making all GUI apps 32-bit, so only one copy of the GUI libraries is loaded. You have two copies of libc loaded, but the memory savings of making the whole GUI 32-bit probably cancels out the wastage of two copies of libc.

4 months ago

in Poster for Obama rally in Berlin (Scripting News) on Scripting News
Dave, have you see this one? A combination of two of your favorite subjects:

http://bethesignal.org/blog/2008/07/22/fail-we-...

4 months ago

in Let’s make data centers obsolete on Broadband Politics
Maybe with a scavenger class you could ensure that these boxes only use "sunk bandwidth" and thus don't impose extra costs on customers or ISPs.

5 months ago

in Is There an Openness-Bandwidth Trade-off? on The Technology Liberation Front
Providing "unlimited neutral 7Mbps" costs an ISP $X/month, while providing "unlimited 7Mbps except P2P" costs dramatically less. An alternate way to look at is that for a fixed $Y/month, an ISP can promise more bandwidth if they can prevent customers from using it, or they can provide less but neutral bandwidth. Brett Glass's Lariat is an example of this phenomenon.

I'd rather have a slower neutral network but I know many of my neighbors would not, so I'm not ready to legislate neutrality either.

6 months ago

in Tunneling your way around ISP traffic manipulation on The Technology Liberation Front
So I should pay for a broken ISP, then pay more for a VPN to fix it? No way.

6 months ago

in Comcast's 250GB limit? (Scripting News) on Scripting News
It is certainly convenient that the long-distance phone network only bills the calling party, but there is a hidden cost in the system: a complex inter-provider settlement system. That system isn't free. Backbone Internet traffic doesn't have a settlement system, making the Internet cheaper overall.
1 reply
mjesales I guess since I pay for the outgoing bandwidth of my webserver (and the incoming on some hosts) - then the customer shouldn't be charged extra for using more. Its readily available, and if it isn't then a ISP needs to address that situation.

7 months ago

in 11 years of Scripting News (Scripting News) on Scripting News
I used your code from 1998-2000 and I've been on Manila since then. I like the idea of the day as the unit of blogging rather than the item.

9 months ago

in Network Neutrality == End-to-End Principle? on The Technology Liberation Front
Different companies use different protocols for the same ends. For video, Akamai uses HTTP while Vuze uses BitTorrent. For VoIP, Vonage uses UDP while Skype uses various protocols. Allowing protocol discrimination thus also allows discrimination between companies, which tilts the playing field. Protocol discrimination also encourages the wasteful cloaking and inspection arms race.

9 months ago

in TPW 35: Network Management Redux on The Technology Liberation Front
I think the term "spoofing" is more commonly used in the network engineering community, possibly because it is not as charged as "forgery". So the people complaining about forgery either aren't very familiar with IP networking or are trying to use terminology to sway the argument in their favor.

10 months ago

in I never learn (Scripting News) on Scripting News
You're not the only one. I ordered a computer for myself around Thanksgiving from NewEgg with 3-day UPS shipping; it actually took 7 days. Then I ordered a JBL Radial for my Mom which was misrouted by UPS and barely arrived in time.

12 months ago

in The HD is woking! (Scripting News) on Scripting News
Maybe Handbrake can convert 'em.
Returning? Login